Roundup
Best Real Estate Lead Generation for New Agents (2026): What It Really Costs
Zillow Premier Agent, Zillow Preferred, Real Geeks, Lofty, CINC and Ylopo compared for new real estate agents, with real 2026 costs, referral fees and the free options to try first.
On this page
- The short answer
- Understand the three ways lead gen is priced
- A quick math example
- Zillow Preferred: no upfront cost, big share at closing
- Zillow Premier Agent: pay for buyer connections
- Real Geeks: your own website plus optional ad packages
- Lofty: managed ads in an all-in-one platform
- CINC: built for teams buying volume
- Ylopo: managed ads on top of your CRM
- What about Realtor.com?
- Before you spend a dollar on leads
- FAQ
Every new agent hears the same pitch: "Buy our leads and you'll close deals in 30 days." Some agents do build a business on paid leads. Many others spend thousands before their first closing. The difference is usually knowing what each lead source really costs, how it gets paid, and whether you have the follow-up system to convert people who aren't ready to buy for six months.
This guide compares the main lead-generation options using each company's own pricing pages (checked November 19, 2026) and public reporting. We haven't run controlled lead-buying tests, and nobody can promise you a conversion rate. We can show you the price structures honestly.
The short answer
- Start free: your sphere, open houses and a basic CRM. Most first deals come from people you already know.
- Pay only at closing: Zillow Preferred. No upfront cost, but you pay a success fee. It's 40% of your commission on seller connections, and it varies by ZIP code and price on buyer connections.
- Pay up front for buyer connections: Zillow Premier Agent. Zillow says the average cost per connection is $223 in major metros and $139 elsewhere.
- Own the website and buy ads: Real Geeks. $399 a month plus a $500 setup fee. Lead packages run $299 to $599 a month.
- Managed multi-channel ads: Lofty, CINC or Ylopo. All quote-based, plus ad spend.
| Tool | Best for | Trial / free plan | Pricing | Strengths | Watch out for | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zillow Preferred | Agents who prefer paying only when a Zillow-sourced deal closes | Application / market availability | Success fee: % of your commission; seller connections 40%; buyer % varies by ZIP and price | No upfront cost, high-intent buyer connections | Large share of your commission; performance standards apply | Check Zillow Preferred pricing |
| Real Geeks | Agents who want an IDX lead-capture website plus CRM | Demo | $399/mo incl. 2 users + $500 one-time setup; lead packages $299-$599/mo | IDX website + CRM + dialer in one, optional managed ad packages | Setup fee and 6- or 12-month commitment terms; ad packages add up fast | Check Real Geeks pricing |
| Lofty | Agents and teams wanting CRM, IDX website and paid lead gen in one platform | Demo / quote | Quote-based; lead-gen add-ons carry a 20% ad management fee | IDX websites, AI assistant, built-in lead generation channels, social tools | No published plan prices; total cost depends heavily on ad spend | Check Lofty pricing |
| CINC | Teams buying large volumes of online buyer and seller leads | Request pricing | Quote-based; ad add-ons start at $200/mo; dialer 3 lines for $75/mo | Lead generation + CRM + AI follow-up built for teams | No published base price; a big commitment for a new solo agent | Check CINC pricing |
| Ylopo | Teams already on Follow Up Boss or BoldTrail who want managed digital ads | Quote | Quote-based (priced by market and database size), plus ad spend | Managed Facebook/Google ads, AI texting and voice, integrates with popular CRMs | Not a CRM on its own; total cost includes ad budget | Check Ylopo pricing |
Understand the three ways lead gen is priced
- Referral or success fee at closing. You pay nothing up front, but you give up a share of your commission. Zillow Preferred works this way. So does Realtor.com's ReadyConnect Concierge, which says agents pay a referral fee only on closed transactions.
- Pay per connection or per month for advertising. Zillow Premier Agent prices by market, and Zillow publishes average costs per connection.
- Platform + ad spend. You pay for a website/CRM platform plus an advertising budget, sometimes with a management fee. Real Geeks, Lofty, CINC and Ylopo work this way.
A new agent with little cash usually prefers option 1, accepting a smaller paycheck in exchange for no risk. An agent with savings and strong follow-up habits may do better with 2 or 3 over time.
A quick math example
Here's a made-up example to show how fees stack up. It isn't a quote. Say you help a seller with a $400,000 home and your side's commission is 2.5%, or $10,000.
- With a 40% success fee, $4,000 goes to the lead source and $6,000 is left.
- If your brokerage split is 70/30, you keep about $4,200 before taxes and expenses.
Now compare that with a paid lead source. If you spend $600 a month for six months ($3,600) and close the same deal, you keep more. But that only holds if a deal actually closes. Run this math with your own numbers before you sign anything.
Zillow Preferred: no upfront cost, big share at closing
Zillow's pricing page explains that when you close with a Zillow Preferred connection, you pay Zillow a percentage of the full commission you expect to earn:
- Seller-originated connections: the success fee is 40% in all markets.
- Buyer-originated connections: the fee varies by market, transaction price and connection delivery date. You can look it up by ZIP code.
- Changes: Zillow can change success fees with 15 days' notice. Changes apply to connections received after that.
Good for: new agents in a market where Zillow Preferred is offered who want leads without upfront spending.
Watch out for: the fee comes out of every closed deal. Factor in your brokerage split too. Your net can be a small fraction of the gross commission.
Zillow Preferred — Agents who prefer paying only when a Zillow-sourced deal closes
See Zillow Preferred pricingZillow Premier Agent: pay for buyer connections
Premier Agent is Zillow's advertising program. Zillow says pricing "varies by market, home values, expected connections, and more." It lists the average cost per connection as $223 in major metros and $139 in non-major metros. Contracts aren't required, though Zillow offers discounts for 6-month contracts.
Good for: agents with cash reserves and the discipline to call every connection instantly and follow up for months.
Watch out for: a connection is a conversation, not a client. Ask Zillow for realistic conversion expectations in your market and plan for months before a closing.
Real Geeks: your own website plus optional ad packages
Real Geeks sells an IDX website and CRM platform for $399 a month, including two users, plus a $500 one-time setup fee. Lead packages are optional:
- Social: Facebook and Instagram listing ads at $299 per package per month, estimated at roughly 20 to 40 buyer leads a month.
- Search: Google and Bing property search ads at $599 per month.
- Seller: Google property valuation ads at $599 per month, estimated at roughly 10 to 15 seller leads a month.
Real Geeks marks its lead estimates with an asterisk. Treat them as estimates, not promises.
Good for: agents who want to own their website and database while buying ads.
Watch out for: 6- or 12-month commitment terms, and a total cost that can approach $1,000 a month with one lead package.
Real Geeks — Agents who want an IDX lead-capture website plus CRM
See Real Geeks pricingLofty: managed ads in an all-in-one platform
Lofty sells managed advertising on Google, Facebook, Instagram and Microsoft, Google Local Services Ads, listing ads and a ZIP-code farming product, all feeding its AI CRM. Pricing is by quote. Lofty discloses a 20% ad management fee on lead-generation purchases.
Good for: agents who want one vendor running the ads, the website and the follow-up AI.
Lofty — Agents and teams wanting CRM, IDX website and paid lead gen in one platform
Get a Lofty quoteCINC: built for teams buying volume
CINC's pricing page lists Solo, Ramp (up to 4 users), Pro (up to 49 users) and Select (50+) plans, all by request. Add-on offers like Facebook buyer and seller leads and CINC AI start at $200 a month, and a dialer is $75 a month for three lines. CINC is generally positioned for teams that buy leads at scale.
Good for: growing teams with ISAs or several agents to work leads.
Ylopo: managed ads on top of your CRM
Ylopo runs digital advertising and AI follow-up and connects to a CRM rather than replacing one. Its pricing is quote-based and depends on your market and database size, plus ad spend. Its ez Referral program requires Follow Up Boss or kvCORE/BoldTrail, which shows where it fits best.
Good for: teams already on Follow Up Boss or BoldTrail.
What about Realtor.com?
Realtor.com's ReadyConnect Concierge page says it delivers pre-screened, live-transferred leads with no upfront cost, and agents pay a referral fee on closed transactions. Some brokerages have told their agents the program is being wound down, so confirm whether it's available in your market before planning around it. Realtor.com also sells other advertising products. Ask a rep for current options and pricing.
Before you spend a dollar on leads
- Load your sphere into a CRM and contact everyone. See best CRM for new agents.
- Hold open houses for other agents' listings. They're free, and you meet buyers face to face.
- Set up a simple website so your name searches lead somewhere. See best IDX websites.
- Set a hard monthly lead budget you can afford for at least six months.
- Track cost per closing, not cost per lead.
FAQ
What's the cheapest way to get real estate leads? Your sphere and open houses cost time, not money. Of the paid options, success-fee programs like Zillow Preferred have no upfront cost.
Are Zillow leads worth it for new agents? They can be, if you respond instantly and follow up long-term. Compare the success fee or connection cost against your net commission after your brokerage split.
Do I need a CRM before buying leads? Yes. Leads without fast, consistent follow-up are wasted money.
Related: Follow Up Boss vs Lofty · BoldTrail vs Lofty